As an insurance professional specializing in condominium association insurance, I believe it is important to understand that the consequences of unauthorized or illegal short-term rentals extend far beyond the immediate liability exposure associated with guests, visitors, and activities taking place within a building.

The impact can reach the association’s entire insurance program.

From an underwriting perspective, insurance companies evaluate not only the physical property but also its occupancy, operations, risk management practices, and overall exposure. A condominium operating with unauthorized short-term rental activity may present a substantially different risk than one with traditional owner occupancy or standard 12-month residential leases.

This distinction matters.

Short-term rentals can introduce increased guest turnover, unfamiliar occupants, security concerns, property damage, and potentially more frequent incidents. These exposures can affect an insurer’s willingness to offer coverage, the terms and conditions available, and ultimately the premiums an association pays.

Perhaps even more concerning is the potential barrier to entry into the insurance marketplace. Some of the most financially sound and desirable insurance companies may decline to consider a condominium altogether if its occupancy or rental practices fall outside their underwriting guidelines. This reduces competition, limits the association’s options, and can leave it dependent on fewer carriers, potentially at substantially higher costs.

In other words, an association may find itself paying more for less favorable coverage simply because its risk profile has changed.

The Greater Concern: The Association and Its Board of Directors

There is another dimension that deserves particular attention: the responsibility and potential personal exposure of the association’s Board of Directors.

Board members have a fiduciary responsibility to act in the best interests of the association and exercise appropriate oversight. When unauthorized rental activity is brought to their attention, ignoring the issue or knowingly allowing it to continue can create serious governance and insurance concerns.

Associations should never assume that their General Liability or Directors & Officers (D&O) policies will automatically protect them in these circumstances.

Coverage depends on the actual policy language, applicable exclusions, the circumstances of the claim, and the conduct of the parties involved. Certain policies contain exclusions addressing illegal acts, fraud, intentional misconduct, or knowing violations. Depending on the circumstances, those provisions could jeopardize coverage for the association or individual board members.

Additionally, knowingly concealing rental activity or providing inaccurate information to an insurance carrier during underwriting or renewal could constitute material misrepresentation and, in certain circumstances, insurance fraud.

The consequences can be significant, potentially including denied claims, rescinded coverage, nonrenewal, and personal legal exposure. Where criminal insurance fraud is established, penalties can include substantial fines and imprisonment, depending on the applicable jurisdiction and severity of the offense.

A Board of Directors should never put the association’s financial security, or its members’ personal assets, at risk by ignoring an exposure that should have been addressed.

There Are Ways to Strengthen an Association’s Insurance Protection

While these circumstances can create extraordinary challenges, there may be additional insurance products, endorsements, and risk-management solutions available to strengthen an association’s overall insurance program and provide additional protection for the association and its directors.

The key is identifying these exposures before a claim occurs, properly disclosing the association’s operations to its insurance professionals, and ensuring the insurance program is structured around the actual risks the community faces.

My message to condominium associations and their Boards is simple: What you don’t properly disclose, address, or manage today could become the very issue that threatens your insurance protection tomorrow.

If your association has questions about short-term rental exposures, insurance eligibility, liability protection, or protecting its Board of Directors, I welcome the opportunity to help.

Please feel free to contact me for a general insurance consultation or assistance evaluating your association’s insurance program.

Wishing everyone a wonderful and blessed holiday season and a very Happy New Year!

Respectfully,